
PE-Backed Portfolio Company: CEO Search
Role
Chief Executive Officer
Organisation
Mid-market private equity firm
Scale
Portfolio company, ~800 employees
Board-mandated CEO search with three credentialed finalists and no evidence-based differentiation method.
Three equally credentialed CEO finalists. Traditional interviewing had produced a divided board with no mechanism for consensus. The decision was trending towards instinct and interpersonal preference, creating significant mis-hire exposure.
- Introduced a structured eight-competency simulation alongside the existing interview process
- Generated scored, timestamped behavioural evidence for each candidate
- Applied consistent, scored criteria across every candidate
- Established a defensible, auditable record for board review
Board Consensus
6 of 7
Directors converged on the same lead candidate after the evidence review
Unresolved Concerns
4 to 1
Material reservations remaining after evidence review
Additional Interviews
1 round removed
Planned final panel stage no longer required
Decision Confidence
6.8 to 8.4
Average director rating, before and after assessment
Result
The organisation moved from a divided, opinion-led process to an appointment grounded in shared behavioural evidence, with the assessment findings shaping the incoming CEO's first-year development plan.
Chief Executive Officer




